‘Wrong Man Arrested’: New CCTV Footage Puts Reiger Park Murder Case Under Scrutiny
Police believe they have arrested the man responsible for the shooting that claimed the lives of two Gauteng Anti-Gang Unit officers and two women in Reiger Park, Ekurhuleni.
However, questions have emerged over whether Reagan Cheslin Collis, 23, is actually the gunman.
A source familiar with the investigation, who has viewed CCTV footage linked to the incident, disputes the police case against Collis and claims that another man may have carried out the shooting.
Collis appeared in the Boksburg Magistrate’s Court on Wednesday, facing four counts of murder, one count of attempted murder, two counts of robbery with aggravating circumstances, as well as charges relating to the possession of unlicensed firearms and ammunition.
His case was postponed to August 25 for a formal bail application.
Police believe Collis is the shooter
Collis was arrested during a multidisciplinary tracing operation following the killings.
The operation resulted in the recovery of two R5 rifles at the KwaDukathole informal settlement in Germiston over the weekend.
Investigators have linked Collis to the shooting, which is believed to have stemmed from a longstanding gang-related conflict.
However, the source who has seen the footage maintains that the evidence does not necessarily identify Collis as the person who fired the shots.
The allegations have not been tested in court, and Collis remains legally presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
Four people killed in Reiger Park
The deadly shooting happened at about 7.30pm on Friday, August 7.
The two police officers who were killed were Anti-Gang Unit members Constable Thapelo Tlomatsana, 29, and Constable Sphiwe Sibeko, 28.
Two civilian women, Roleen Lessing and Jaydin Margerman, were also killed.
According to Gauteng police spokesperson Brigadier Brenda Muridili, the officers were part of a crime-prevention team conducting patrols in the area when they heard gunshots.
They reportedly drove towards the source of the shooting and were allegedly ambushed.
The officers were attacked only a short distance from where the two women had been shot.
Sibeko was laid to rest in Springs on Saturday, while Tlomatsana is scheduled to be buried in Zebediela, Limpopo, on Sunday.
CCTV footage raises questions
According to the source, the shooting began after a red Volkswagen Polo carrying the two women stopped outside the property belonging to Collis’ grandmother.
CCTV footage allegedly shows one of the women getting out of the vehicle and walking towards a nearby shop, while the other remained in the driver’s seat.
A silver-grey Polo hatchback then allegedly drove past the women’s vehicle.
According to the source, a man was dropped off from the silver-grey vehicle near the area where the shooting subsequently took place.
When the woman returned to the red Polo, the alleged gunman approached the vehicle.
He allegedly opened fire, first targeting the driver’s side before shooting towards the passenger.
Both women were reportedly sitting in the front of the vehicle.
Who was the gunman?
The source claims a community patroller saw the shooter but could not clearly identify his face.
The alleged gunman was reportedly wearing a dark blue or black hoodie and red tracksuit pants.
The footage allegedly shows him approaching the red Polo before opening fire.
After the shooting, a man identified by the source as Collis is allegedly seen inside the yard near the property.
He reportedly runs towards a fence and appears to confront the shooter.
According to the source, Collis allegedly told the man:
“I saw you. I saw you.”
The source claims the footage shows Collis wearing a hoodie, blue jeans and white sneakers — clothing that differs from the description given for the alleged gunman.
Collis allegedly checks the vehicle
The source further alleges that Collis subsequently tried to leave the yard to establish what had happened.
He is allegedly seen opening the driver’s door of the red Polo, pulling up the handbrake and switching off the vehicle’s music.
A police vehicle can then reportedly be seen approaching the area.
The vehicle later collided with a fence at Lakeside Primary School.
According to the source, Collis was later seen walking outside his grandmother’s house.
The footage allegedly shows the gunman running towards the silver-grey Polo, which is believed to have been used as the getaway vehicle.
Police officers were allegedly attacked moments later
The violence did not end with the attack on the two women.
The two Anti-Gang Unit officers were reportedly shot approximately two houses away from where the women had been attacked.
Community patrollers are said to have witnessed the shooting.
The sequence of events is now a crucial part of the investigation, particularly if the CCTV footage can establish where Collis was at the time each of the shootings took place.
Police have not publicly detailed all the evidence they say links Collis to the killings.
Alleged gang rivalry
The shooting is believed to be connected to an ongoing dispute involving Collis, people associated with him and a group known locally as the Sour Boys.
According to the source, Collis and his family allegedly received a Facebook message approximately two hours before the shooting warning that the group was coming for him and his family.
The alleged threat has not been independently established.
The source claims the group subsequently arrived in the area and that the shooting followed.
It is further alleged that the gunman was known to Collis and that Collis provided police with information about what had happened after the shooting.
If confirmed, the alleged warning could become an important part of the investigation as detectives attempt to establish the motive and identify everyone involved.
Allegations of police torture
Separate allegations have also emerged concerning Collis’ treatment following his arrest.
It has been alleged that he was tortured by police, with a family member reportedly witnessing the alleged incident.
These allegations have not been independently confirmed.
They could become relevant to the bail proceedings and any subsequent legal challenges if formally raised before the court.
Hawks asked to explain evidence
Questions have been put to law enforcement about the evidence supporting Collis’ arrest and whether investigators have considered other suspects.
Among the questions are whether CCTV footage was obtained and analysed, whether the footage supports or contradicts the allegation that Collis was the shooter, and whether investigators have identified another possible gunman.
The Hawks have also been asked about the alleged gang rivalry and whether investigators received information about threats against Collis or his associates before the shooting.
Gauteng police referred questions to the Hawks, with Hawks spokesperson Colonel Katlego Mogale yet to respond.
Investigation remains ongoing
The case is now entering an important stage as investigators attempt to piece together what happened during the deadly sequence of shootings.
The recovery of two R5 rifles could potentially provide investigators with forensic evidence, while CCTV footage and witness statements may help establish the movements of the suspects and victims.
For the prosecution, establishing exactly who fired the fatal shots will be critical.
For Collis, the distinction could prove decisive as he faces four murder charges.
His next court appearance is scheduled for August 25, when his formal bail application is expected to be heard.
Until the evidence is tested in court, the competing versions of events remain allegations.
























